Thursday, October 9, 2014

Gotham Pilot Episode Review




by Snow Drift
 
Gotham is a new DC Comics television series created by Bruno Heller and starring Ben McKenzie (Detective James Gordon), Donal Logue (Detective Harvey Bullock), David Mazouz (Bruce Wayne), and Jada Pinkett Smith (Fish Mooney), among many others. The series, which aired its pilot episode September 22nd, will broadcast through Fox.



Gotham’s scenery was a mix between modern and gothic architecture with some early 20th Century aspects, which gives the viewers a relative feel of a city that is both of our time and unique in its existence. There is a sense of grim darkness to it without it being too overwhelming. Portraying Gotham and its population as mostly corrupt helps to quickly establish the kind of world James Gordon will have to deal with on a daily basis: one that has the power to break him if he even flinches. By additionally showing characters that believe in justice, such as Renee Montoya (Victoria Cartagena), and villains that are more than just cardboard cutouts, like Carmine Falcone (John Doman), the episode demonstrates that the series will neither be monotonous in its characterization nor dull in its plot. However, even though the general atmosphere of the episode is dark and gritty, there is a sort of over-the-topness, like when the butcher came to kill Gordon and Bullock, which may seem jarring to some viewers but enjoyable to others, depending on each person’s tastes.




In terms of characterization, the episode presented each character with a sense of distinguished identity and the possibility to broaden their stories. Gotham does not go with a superhero twist from the start, but it portrays characters as having a certain quality to them that might develop into a more identifying one in the future. Since this series is based on the early years of the Gotham-centric characters, it is understandable that none of them will necessarily jump right into tights costumes out of nowhere; although it feels strange when certain characters act differently from their usual selves. A few perfect example are Alfred Pennyworth’s (Sean Pertwee) more disciplined, annoyed and serious manner, and Oswald Cobblepot’s (Robin Lord Taylor) more outwardly cowardice portrayal. These characters still need to be developed into the ones that comic book readers know and love. In terms of acting, I’m still not entirely sold on McKenzie and Logue’s performance, yet but I did love Pinkett Smith and Mazouz. The rest, although well done, still need development.

Unfortunately, there are some aspects I did not particularly like. The dialogue at times felt a bit too poetic when the moment didn’t necessarily call for it. For an episode that established itself as down-to-Earth, to an extent, those instances came on felt out of place. This also goes for the cinematography, which was relatively well done except in a scene that zoomed in on Gordon’s face, which broke the flow of the scene. Meanwhile, although I do love to see comic book characters making an appearance in television series, there must be a reasonable introduction to them. This was something Gotham lacked. It was nice to see Edward Nygma (Corey Michael Smith), Ivy Pepper (Clare Foley), and Selina Kyle (Camren Bicondova), and but it was a bit too much for a first episode. Their individual introductions should have been more dispersed and less cluttered. It would have helped the shows progression flow instead of shove characters in the viewers’ face. 



TV Series Review: Community






by Rogue

The Basics:
Community is not your typical geeky sitcom. It’s a show by the great Dan Harmon (cocreator
of the Adult Swim animated television series Rick and Morty) and it stars an
ensemble cast. The premise of the show is a group of seven different personalities form
a study group for a Spanish class (taught by a Chinese professor) in Greendale
Community College. The comedy of the show is fresh and original and literally
indescribable. It’s aired on NBC for five seasons, while the sixth will air on Yahoo!
Screen.

The Cast and Characters:
1. Jeff Winger (Joel McHale) - a con artist at heart, he got caught at his law firm lying
about having a bachelor’s degree and enrolls at Greendale Community College for a
“quickie” degree.

2. Britta Perry (Gillian Jacobs) - a high school drop out, former anarchist and social
activist.

3. Abed Nadir (Danny Pudi) - a Palestinian-Polish film student suspected of having
Asperger’s syndrome but has an encyclopedic knowledge of TV shows and movies.

4. Shirley Bennett - a recently divorced single mother and vocal Christian.

5. Annie Edison (Allison Brie) - the youngest, people pleasing and over achieving
student who lost her scholarship to a prestigious university when she became
addicted to Adderall.

6. Troy Barnes (Donald Glover a.k.a. Childish Gambino) - a former high school star
quarterback who lost his scholarship due to injury, he instantly bonds with Abed and
embraces his geeky, goofy side

7. Pierce Hawthorne (Chevy Chase) - an old, racist and sexist millionaire who enrolls at
Greendale out of boredom

8. Ben Chang (Ken Jeong) - the slightly deranged Chinese Spanish teacher. Together
they study for Ben Chang’s ridiculous Spanish class and have to put up with the
antics of the exuberant and lively Dean Craig Pelton.

9. Craig Pelton (Jim Rash) - the exuberant and lively Dean who desperately wants
Greendale to be taken as a university, instead of a community college.

My Top 5 Episodes:
1. “Modern Warfare” (S01E23) - after the Dean announces the prize for the winner of
the school paintball game, it breaks out into an out all war. The episode heavily
references and parodies action movies and post apocalyptic films such as Die Hard,
Terminator, Rambo etc.
2. “Abed’s Uncontrollable Christmas” (S02E11) - a freaking STOP MOTION Christmasthemed
episode. STOP MOTION ANIMATION!
3. “Advanced Dungeons & Dragons” (S02E14) - the study group notice a fellow student
nicknamed “Fat Neil” is lonely and suicidal so they play a game of Advanced
Dungeons and Dragons with him, but Pierce feels left out and does his best to ruin
the game.
4. “Digital Estate Planning” (S03E20) - Pierce’s father has died but in order to claim his
inheritance he and the study group have to play an 8 bit console game reminiscent of
Nintendo and Sega systems, with a bit of Minecraft thrown into the mix.
5. “G.I. Jeff” (S05E11) - A FULL animated episode stylized after the 1980’s show G.I.
Joe.

Other Fun Bits:
These are just MY top 5 episodes, but there’s TONS more. Zombie themed episodes, an Apollo 13 episode, a glee parody episode, conspiracy theory episode, a Law & Order episode, hidden jokes and easter eggs everywhere. This show is genius and EVERYBODY needs to go check it out now!

Monday, October 6, 2014

Comic Review: Avengers vs. X-Men 0-12 (April to October 2012)




Publisher: Marvel Comics
Language: English

The Writers:
1. Jason Aaron
2. Brian Michael Bendis (winner of 5 Eisner Awards)
3. Ed Brubaker (winner of 4 Eisner Awards)
4. Matt Fraction (winner of 1 Eisner Award)
5. Jonathan Hickman

The Pencillers:
1. John Romita, Jr.
2. Oliver Coipel
3. Adam Kubert

by Rogue

Synopsis:
The Phoenix Force is approaching Earth, and in the events of Avengers: X-Sanction we
learn Hope Summers is its next host. Unfortunately the X-Men and Avengers have very
different ideas on how to handle the situation and it breaks out into a war.
*NOTE: This event closes an arc that started with House of M in 2005 and it launches
Marvel into their Marvel NOW! relaunch initiative.

Review:

Story:
The concept is not particularly original since we’ve already read heroes battling heroes
(Civil War), but AvX does contain some unexpected twists and turns. It should not be read
as a stand alone, it has a poor introduction to the events and characters, and references
past events. I suggest reading the “Dark Phoenix Saga” (The X-Men #129-138), Avengers:
Disassembled (Avengers #500-503), House of M, Messiah Complex, X-Men: Second
Coming, and Avengers:X-Sanction. The event starts out action packed and well written,
but as it reaches the middle it loses focus, it gets boring and drags on forever. If the writers
would have used a couple more issues for the set up and premise of the story instead of
rushing headfirst into the action and conflict, they wouldn’t have had a climax at the 5th
issue and then had to drag out 7 issues of falling action. It’s not a bad story, it simply didn’t
need 12 issues to be told.

Execution:
Some issues were more successful than others. Issues by Brian Michael Bendis (#0, #1,
#8, and #11) were the best executed in my opinion, but sometime after issue #6 it gets
messy. Everything from issue #7 to #10 is the equivalent of a Zack Snyder movie (300,
Watchmen, Man of Steel), loud, lots of explosions, and could be done in one issue. It was
just too much. The most worrying thing was that I could identify which writer wrote which
issue, they had their stamp all over the page making it impossible for the story to flow. One
writer (or two at the most) should have done the script for the entire 12 issues to keep the
event clean and consistent.

Artwork:
Out of the three artists that illustrated AvX, I would have to single out Oliver Coipel as the
most successful, and occasionally John Romita, Jr. They were able to illustrate clean and
concisely a battle between a cast of 78+ characters. Unfortunately Adam Kubert wasn’t as
successful and it shows in his panels, they’re crowded, muddled and inconsistent.
Characterization and Character Development:

For an event called Avengers vs. X-Men, there’s not a whole lot of Avenger action going
on with the exception of Captain America and the Scarlet Witch (who is not exactly an
Avenger at this moment). On the other hand the X-Men are everywhere; Cyclops, Hope
Summers, and a random cast that I still don’t understand why they were chosen.
Personally, the only character who I saw change throughout the event was Cyclops, who
despite not being a favorite of mine, I was glad in the shift in his demeanor after 48+ years.
Issue #11 is my favorite out of the entire event, because it illustrates the relationship
between Cyclops and Xavier that has been strained since the events of X-Men:Deadly
Genesis (I highly recommend this title). Other than that, the characters weren’t nearly as
interesting as they have been in past events.

Conclusion:
This event is not essential for anyone interested in reading Marvel NOW! I appreciated
some aspects of it but it is not at the quality that it should have been. It’s not awful, but it’s
not great either.